Why Residents are Choosing to Rent vs Buy in Today’s Housing Market

Redwood Living, Inc. • March 7, 2023

People looking to move are asking the age-old question: is it better to rent or buy their next home?

Residents weigh a multitude of factors when deciding whether to rent or buy their home. In addition to lifestyle and personal needs, current economic conditions such as rising interest rates, persistent inflation and housing market shortages are making the decision even more complex.


For many, homeownership might be the ultimate goal, but maybe it’s not the best fit for today. Below are just a few reasons why people are leaning toward rental life instead of homeownership. 


They are carefully considering their costs

In this inflationary environment, many people are debating the economics of buying a home or leasing an apartment. According to Bankrate, as of March 1, the current average 30-year fixed-mortgage rate is hovering around 7%. If someone buys a $250,000 home with a $50,000 down payment with a 30-year fixed mortgage rate of 7.4%, the mortgage payment will be comparable to an all-inclusive rent payment – but also require other financial considerations such as taxes, insurance and maintenance. 


Of course, everyone’s financial picture is different and there are many variables in this equation, but there are some common costs that people are comparing. 


  • Upfront costs when buying a home will include the down payment, inspection, closing costs and any necessary repairs at move-in. Renters are typically only required to pay processing and application fees along with a security deposit. 
  • Monthly costs for both homeowners and renters will include either their mortgage or rent, water, gas, electric, insurance and sewer/trash. Homeowners will additionally be strapped with property taxes and property maintenance costs, and will likely pay more for insurance than renters
  • When selling a house, homeowners might get hit with a prepayment penalty on their loan, title search/notary/escrow fees, a mortgage balance payoff, real estate agent commissions, closing costs/credits to the buyer, transfer tax, capital gains tax and a home warranty. Renters, on the other hand, will typically just pay for any damages to their unit and a potential buy-out fee if they are moving out before their lease is up.


They want to leave maintenance behind 

As a homeowner, there is no denying that the list of home maintenance duties and repair projects can feel never-ending. Just a few of the indoor headaches include plumbing problems, faulty HVAC systems, replacing air filters, maintaining appliances and pest extermination. The list continues outdoors with landscaping, snow removal, window washing, roof repairs, gutter cleaning and more. 


For renters, these worries are things of the past. All they need to do is start a work order and let the professionals do the rest. Plus, there is some peace of mind knowing that having on-site property management and maintenance teams means emergency requests can often be addressed within 24 hours. 


They’re benefiting from flexible lease terms

Homeownership means commitment – to the location, the mortgage and of course, the house itself. Sometimes life calls for something more flexible. Maybe someone needs short-term accommodations while building a home. Or perhaps an empty nester is trying to balance home life and extended travel plans. Whatever the reason, apartment living will not lock anyone into a long-term arrangement – unless that’s the preference. Oftentimes the freedom that comes with renting will inspire a resident to turn their apartment into their forever home. 


They’re discovering nontraditional rental options 

Apartment living does not always mean multi-floor buildings with noisy neighbors, dimly lit hallways, broken down elevators and inconvenient parking. Residents looking to rent an apartment without sacrificing the comfort of a single-family home are finding more options than ever before. 


For example, living in a Redwood Neighborhood means that all apartment homes are single-story with two bedrooms and two bathrooms, attached garages, private entrances, personal patios, eat-in kitchens, vaulted ceilings, large closets, pet-friendly accommodations and many other advantages that make every square inch feel more like home. 

  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button
  • Slide title

    Write your caption here
    Button

For multifamily investors, this type of “horizontal apartment” is an attractive asset, because despite all the variables that can change with the market, this style of housing will often appeal to people that are transitioning from homeownership, those bridging the gap between homes, or those that want to buy but are simply not ready. 


To learn more about investing with Redwood, call 216.360.9441 or fill out a contact form.


Redwood Living Inc BTR Tenant Survey Flooring and storage
By Redwood Living, Inc. November 27, 2024
Ample storage and quality flooring are among the amenities build-to-rent tenants are seeking most as they decide where to live. Storage is a particular pain point, especially in horizontal apartments, according to the 2024 Build-to-Rent Tenant Survey.
More build-to-rent tenants say they rent because they want to
By Redwood Living, Inc. October 25, 2024
An increased number of build-to-rent tenants say they’re renting by choice, according to the 2024 Build-to-Rent Tenant Survey.
Midway through 2024, Redwood reports strong results
By Redwood Living, Inc. August 15, 2024
Redwood reports out on its success thus far in 2024, with an outlook on the rest of the year.
Amid market fluctuation, multifamily can remain key investment strategy
By Redwood Living, Inc. August 9, 2024
The CBRE 2024 Global Multifamily Investor Intentions Survey found that among all major real estate sectors, “multifamily remained the top acquisition target this year."
2024 NAA Top Employer
By Redwood Living, Inc. June 11, 2024
The results are in – Redwood has been named a 2024 NAA Top Employer by the National Apartment Association, adding to its list of national accolades that recognize outstanding company culture.
Pet friendliness is a heavy draw in build-to-rent communities
By Redwood Living, Inc. May 9, 2024
As many as two-thirds of residents say pet friendliness is a very important part of their housing decision. Find out what else the survey discovered.
Why they lease: Build-to-rent tenants cite location as their top decision driver
By Redwood Living, Inc. April 15, 2024
Part4 of the BTR Tenant Survey results, by the New Home Trends Institute, talks about location as a factor influencing tenant home choice.
BTR Tenant Survey highlights importance of on-site maintenance
By Redwood Living, Inc. April 2, 2024
Part 3 of the BTR Tenant Survey results, by the New Home Trends Institute, highlighting maintenance importance to renters.
In transition: Build-to-rent communities attract residents on the move
By Redwood Living, Inc. March 1, 2024
Part 2 of the BTR Tenant Survey results, by the New Home Trends Institute, part of John Burns Research & Consulting.
The affluence effect: Build-to-rent tenants reflect higher incomes, former homeownership
By Redwood Living, Inc. February 16, 2024
Read how income and past homeownership plays into who rents in BTR. Data is part of a 2023 survey for the New Home Trends Institute, part of John Burns Research & Consulting, which Redwood Living, Inc. participated in along with several others in the industry.
More Posts
Share by: